Nutrition, Osteoporosis

Are you dense or what?

Bone density has captivated the minds and worries of most women who have reached the age of 45 and beyond.  Why?  Because the media, the conventional medical community, and pharmaceutical companies have successfully convinced us that we face an inevitable loss of bone density as we age.  Is it true?  Is it inevitable that we’ll lose bone density as our bodies accumulate years?  Is this loss of bone density a natural progression of aging?

Today I put my stake in the ground and answer, “NO!”  We all age.  Our bodies change in a rhythm established by nature.  This rhythm exists but it isn’t as destructive as you think or you have been led to believe.  We can’t control everything but we are not defenseless, at the mercy of nature. By making some simple changes to your diet and lifestyle,  you can significantly improve your current and future bone health.

BEYOND CALCIUM: KEY NUTRIENTS FOR HEALTHY BONES

I’m sure you already know the importance of dietary calcium for building and maintaining strong, dense bones.  Calcium is only one of seventeen nutrients involved in healthy bone metabolism: vitamins: A, C, D, K, B6, B12,  and folate; minerals: boron, copper, magnesium, manganese, phosphorus, silica, and zinc; essential fatty acids and protein (Lanou & Castleman, 2009, p. 97-99).  Fortunately, the foods we evolved to thrive on supply these nutrients in the proper proportions: fruits, vegetables, nuts, and clean proteins (i.e., grass-fed beef, pasture-raised poultry and eggs, and wild-caught fish).

WHY THE EMPHASIS ON PLANT-BASED FOODS?

Pile generous portions of organic whole plant-based foods on your plate and add modest amounts of clean proteins to create a bone-building, bone-sparing environment inside your body.  Why the emphasis on plant-based foods?  Your body performs at its best in an alkaline environment.  Fruits and vegetables have an alkalizing effect on your body, whereas a high consumption of animal protein disrupts the body’s pH balance, making the body more acidic.

To buffer acidity, the body draws calcium from your bones, resulting in loss of bone mass, the exact opposite outcome you want to achieve!  Studies have shown that vegetarians experience less bone mass loss in their 60’s onward than omnivores even though both groups start out with equal BMD (bone mineral density) in their 20-40’s (Pizzorno & Murray, 2013, p. 1668).  You don’t have to banish meat from your plate, just give it a bit less real estate.

WHAT ABOUT DAIRY, THE “BEST” DIETARY SOURCE OF CALCIUM?

The ads sponsored by the National Dairy Council imply that milk provides the richest source of dietary calcium.  In reality, most leafy greens have more calcium in milligrams per serving than cow’s milk and higher nutrient density (i.e., nutrient bang per calorie) than cow’s milk, cheese, and yogurt.  For example, a one-cup serving of turnip greens weighs in at 12.3 nutrient density of calcium versus the 3.3 of cow’s milk (Mateljan, 2015, p. 942).

Other health authorities (National Osteoporosis Foundation and the Dietary Guidelines for Americans) recommend we consume low- or non-fat milk, eat dairy foods, and take calcium pills to prevent osteoporosis.  However, the countries that consume the most milk, dairy, and calcium have the world’s highest rates of hip fractures!  In fact, total calcium consumption among women in China, Peru, Sri Lanka, and many other non-Western countries only reaches 50% of the recommended 1,000 mg/day, yet these countries experience very low fracture rates (Lanou & Castleman, 2009, p. 9).

Perhaps the health authorities have it wrong with this emphasis on consumption of dairy and calcium.  No nutrient works alone.  Remember, bone health relies on an interplay of seventeen nutrients in the right proportions.

WANT TO LEARN MORE?

Join me at The 3rd Act Women’s Retreat: Renewing Your Purpose and Passion Midlife to dive deeper into the dietary and lifestyle changes that can help you stave off the “inevitable” diseases of midlife including osteoporosis, osteoarthritis, atherosclerosis and cardiovascular disease, type 2 diabetes, hypertension and Alzheimer’s disease.

WHAT WILL YOU DO NEXT?

What moves will you make and/or actions will you take today on your path to a healthy third-act and beyond?  Share your ideas via the comments below.

REFERENCES

Lanou, A. J., & Castleman, M. (2009). Building bone vitality: a revolutionary diet plan to prevent bone loss and reverse osteoporosis. New York: McGraw-Hill.

Mateljan, G. (2015). The world’s healthiest foods: the force for change to optimal with health-promoting foods and nutrient-rich cooking (1st ed.). Seattle, WA.

Pizzorno, J. E., & Murray, M. T. (Eds.). (2013). Textbook of natural medicine (4th ed). St. Louis, Mo: Elsevier/Churchill Livingstone.

Holistic Health

Hot Flashes: WebMD, why is there no option for “Never”?

While reading an article on WebMD, a dialogue box popped up asking me if I would be willing to participate in a survey.  Normally, I click, “No thanks” and proceed with my original task.  This time I decided to give it a go since the survey would only take 5 minutes to complete.  So, I began answering basic demographic info such as my age and sex.  Given my responses, the survey began to ask me about my menses status.  I selected the option, “post-menopause”.

The next question asked me how long I have experienced hot flashes.  The options from which I could choose started with “less than 6 months”.  There was no option for “Never”. What’s up with that?

Why does the team at WebMD assume I have had hot flashes?  I offer an answer to my own question for which I have no proof (give me a few days and I will): the medical community assumes perimenopause and menopause will not go smoothly and that a woman in this phase of her life will experience symptoms.

To play nice, I selected the response, “less than 6 months”.  The next question asked me to describe the severity of the hot flashes I experienced.  At this point, I closed the survey.  I was not going to play this game of manipulative surveying techniques.  This survey had a blatant bias.

Had I continued to answer the questions of this survey, who knows how my inaccurate data would have been used by WebMD?  I suspect they would use it to share statistics with the general public regarding the incidence and severity of hot flashes in post-menopausal women.  Such a publication would continue to perpetuate the fallacy that all women will experience an undesired symptom(s) while making the transition from menses to menopause.

Based on the clinical trials, epidemiological studies, and other research conducted across the globe that I’ve read over the last 20 years, symptoms are NOT a given during perimenopause and menopause.  The average American woman’s experience is not necessarily the experience of women in other parts of the world.

I won’t attempt to guess the game WebMD is playing with this survey.  I’ll use this survey as the impetus to write a series of posts about the realities of what to expect in perimenopause, menopause, and post-menopause.  I’ll back up what I write with validated science.  Stay tuned.

If you have a specific nutrition question pertaining to perimenopause or menopause, please post it in the comments.  I’ll do my best to provide an answer.

To your health,

Catie